The Concorde: A supersonic failure

by birtanpublished on August 4, 2020

This episode is brought to you by Trends Trends is where successful founders and investors get access to high-quality information and connections Join the community and try Trends today by visiting trendsco/deal Today, we take to the skies This plane broke grounds with its technology, speed and looks But it was a financial failure What looked like the future of aviation instead became a luxury item for a select few And though it was very safe for most of its history, one crash sealed an already bleak

Fate, as to how we fly changed But, when it flew, this plane made us dream of the future of aviation In this episode of Forensics, we talk about Concorde After World War II, the world grew obsessed with flying supersonic Chuck Yeager broke the sound barrier in 1947 and, by 1953, experimental planes reached Mach 2, twice the speed of sound*

So, for countries like the United States, France, and the United Kingdom, it seemed only natural to build a supersonic transport or SST for short In fact, the UK started talks of an SST as far back as 1954 By 1959, the Government had requested two companies, Bristol and Hawker Siddeley, to come up with designs for a plane that could carry 150 passengers across the Atlantic at Mach 2 No small task Bristol won with its design, the 223: a delta-wing aircraft, carrying about 100 passengers and

Capable of speeds up to Mach 22 In theory, it could go faster, but at the time, the aluminum alloys available would soften at higher speeds Not something you want when you’re flying at 1500 mph Meanwhile, the French were also coming up with ideas of their own but in another direction France believed that a large, transatlantic SST was already in the minds of the British

And the US, so they opted for a smaller, midrange SST to avoid competition The winning design came from the now-defunct company Sud-Aviation and its Super- Caravelle But the French had no engines powerful enough to go supersonic The British needed someone to split the bill with And It would be a VERY BIG bill So, in 1960, the French technical director Pierre Sartre met with Bristol executives

To talk about their respective ideas The Super Caravelle and the Bristol 223 were both beautiful When they met, the British were shocked to see that both designs were almost identical Well, it turns out that Geoffrey Rippon, who worked at the Ministry of Aviation and was avidly in favor of European integration, just handed classified documents to the French

Strangely enough, this turned out great! Both sides had come up with basically the same plane, which meant there was very little in the way of creative differences But there still were some The French insisted on the smaller, mid-range plane, while the British still wanted to cross the Atlantic, with at least 150 passengers At least, both agreed on the speed: Mach 20 A major merger, including Bristol, created the British Aircraft Corporation

(BAC) in 1959 and BAC insisted on looking for other allies in the quest for an SST, like the US But Boeing and Lockheed rejected the idea The Americans opted to work on their own, rather than sharing knowledge with BAC France was still the best bet So, in 1962, both sides signed an initial agreement that would handcuff them until the project’s completion Clauses within it made any cancellation far more expensive than finishing

The plane The name: Concorde By the way, let’s talk about the name Urban legend has it, as there’s very little evidence, that a BAC executive was having lunch with his family and someone, reading a thesaurus, suggested the word concord All we know is that BAC proposed the name to the French, and they approved it Well, not quite The French word Concorde and the English word concord both mean

Agreement, harmony, or union Ironically, neither side could agree, and a question came up: with or without an E? The initial suggestion was Concorde (with an E) but Prime Minister Harold McMillan immediately changed it to Concord (without an E) But then, at the first roll-out in France in 1967, Minister of Technology Tony Benn went back to Concorde (with an E) And this really pissed the British So, to douse the anger, Benn justified the E as standing for Excellence, England,

Europe and the Entente Agreements between both nations in 1904 Smooth going, Tony From the start, Concorde was a tough build First, the engines The initial idea was to use the Bristol Siddeley 22R engine, but it could only fly at Mach 22 for 45 minutes, which wasn’t enough It took them up to 1968 to get to the final engine design, the Olympus 593 afterburning turbojet With an extremely high thermal efficiency

During supersonic flight, the 593 was powerful But very, very thirsty Then came the fuel tanks Concorde had 17 tanks including two trim tanks to balance the aircraft during transonic flight So, engineers had to come with an entirely new system that would transfer fuel constantly from one tank to the other to help balance the plane In the 60s With pen and paper Heat was also an issue As an aircraft flies faster, air compresses and creates drag over

The entire surface This heats up and expands the aircraft, so much so, that gaps formed all around the cabin and cockpit There’s even a picture of a flight engineer’s cap stuck once the aircraft shrunk back to its original form To work around this heating, engineers had to design cooling mechanisms such as heat sinks and heat-reflecting visors in the cockpit By the way, visibility was minimal, so they had to adapt a drooping nose to allow pilots to see when they took off and landed

All this meant one thing: costs skyrocketed from 70M pounds at the time to 13 BN pounds! But, hey, it crossed the Atlantic in three and a half hours! Though Concorde was revealed to the public in 1967, it didn’t fly until March 1969 and didn’t go supersonic until October of that year And for France and the UK, the pressure was on

Boeing had conjured an all-out SST, the 2707 Mach 3, 200 passengers A promising sale, so much so, that 26 airlines had reserved deliveries for it But, fortunately for Concorde cost overrun, environmental concerns and political pressure meant that the 2707 never took off Then, there was the Soviet Union In 1968, six months before Concorde’s first flight, they flew their version of an SST, the Tupolev Tu-144, and shocked the world

I mean, it looks identical What the hell? Everyone was just copying each other back then It was so similar, the press dubbed it the Concordski And yes, the Soviets were first It even flew supersonic first But again, fortunately for Concorde, the Tu-144 was a complete failure For now, back to Concorde The first two units, F-001 and F-002, appeared in the 1969 Paris Air Show They were to become selling points because both countries

Needed buyers fast So, in 1971, F-001 embarked in a sales tour across the Atlantic, marking the first-ever SST flight across the Atlantic One year later, F-002 took to the East And initial interest was very high, as Boeing’s 2707 was canceled, but short-lived A total of 18 airlines, at some point, placed orders for Concorde American Airlines did so as far back as 1964 and the potential buyers spanned the globe: Iran Air, Qantas,

Japan Airlines and Air Canada, just to name a few But the early seventies weren’t kind to Concorde The spike in development costs caused prices to go from $20 million per unit to $40 million or even $60 million per unit Then came the 1973 Paris Air Show Both Concorde and the Tu-144 were on hand, showing off their prowess, but the Russian airplane plummeted to the ground and crashed Why it happened still debated today But this made potential buyers of an SST skeptical

It didn’t stop there The Oil Crisis spiked fuel prices in the middle of Concorde’s promotion and, as you might remember, the 593 engines drank fuel like crazy And I want to set just one example Jim O’Sullivan, former chief engineer at British Airways explained that a Boeing 737 could burn two tons of fuel from London to Amsterdam Concorde burned those same two tons while taxiing from the gate to the takeoff point

Think about that Two tons Just taxiing Plus, it flew at 60 000 ft, higher than any other commercial plane, which meant possible irreversible damage to the ozone layer No wonder environmental protection groups protested Concorde’s existence And most airlines took notice, mainly because there were other options It only carried 100 passengers but burned the same amount of fuel a 747 used in a flight twice as far with three or four times the passengers And, unlike the 747, Concorde

Couldn’t fly anywhere When an aircraft flies faster than the speed of sound, it generates shockwaves that release a lot of energy in the form of noises similar to explosions These are called sonic booms and can be heard for miles Concorde was no exception Noisy takeoffs and deafening fly-bys immediately raised red flags and many countries forbid the plane from flying above them altogether In fact,

United States had initially prohibited the aircraft from landing in the US, so the coveted North Atlantic route seemed useless Eventually, the US did grant permission, but it couldn’t fly supersonic over land So, in flights such as Paris to Mexico via Washington DC, Concorde had to fly subsonic from Washington to the Gulf of Mexico Only then could it go back to supersonic BAC and Aerospatiale, the company that merged with Sud Aviation, were faced with a

Hard sale: too thirsty, too few passengers, limited range and it couldn’t fly supersonic overland By 1973, 12 airlines had canceled their orders, and others would follow Still, both France and the UK needed to push the plane into operation British Overseas Airways Corporation (BOAC), later British Airways, and Air France both ordered 6 With 2 more units added later These 14 units would be the only commercially operational Concordes

After its first commercial flight, on January 21, 1976, some alliances did appear, with Singapore Airlines and Braniff, for example But paltry ticket sales and land restrictions eventually made them useless Other interesting routes included London-Bahrain, London-Barbados, Paris-Caracas and Paris-Rio de Janeiro But it was just too expensive; tickets doubled the most expensive first-class tickets in subsonic alternatives By 1982, Air France had canceled all flights except New York-

Paris; British Airways held on for a bit longer, but by 1994, it too canceled all its routes except New York-London All wasn’t lost, though Charter flights operated regularly, and one particular group loved Concorde: the rich and the famous Champagne, caviar, and crossing the Atlantic in just three and a half hours lured Sting, Elton John, Cindy Crawford, and plenty of other rich and famous individuals It was usual to see businessmen travel from NYC to London and back in one day

This gave Concorde some life and, from 1976 until its retirement in 2003, the Concorde flew 25 million passengers in 50 thousand flights It brought some of the luxuries of flying and national pride to two nations But its high operating costs gradually rendered it impractical And it wasn’t invincible In July 2000, Air France flight 4590 crashed just after takeoff, killing 113 people A

Metal strip from a previous airplane punctured the left main wheel and when it burst, it sent fragments into the fuel tank Fuel ignited, the plane was inoperable and crashed two minutes after takeoff The remaining operational Concordes were grounded until reinforcements to their structures were made, with lasted one year and cost British Airways and Air France $150 million

It flew again, coincidentally, on 9-11, and landed just before the attacks It carried 100 British Airways employees as a symbol of its return Then it flew commercially in November 2001 But aviation had changed, and the first-class market collapsed Cost-cutting and safety restrictions meant airlines now looked to save even more money, something Concorde wasn’t good at

The crash only damaged an already weakened reputation And, just two years after its return to service, both Air France and British Airways retired Concorde, and with, traveling supersonic Excluding the tragedy in 2000, it was a very safe aircraft, having no other accident involving human life Plus, Concorde was designed and built before the advent of mainstream computer use in aircraft design So, why hasn’t there been another supersonic

Transport? Well, it’s not easy A profitable SST needs to have the technology to lessen sonic boom, fly at Mach 2, carry plenty of passengers and have enough range to fulfill multiple routes But, if engineers came up with Concorde decades ago, then certainly they can do it in the near future So, if you want your own SST, just copy someone else’s idea That’s what everybody did back then, and it seemed to work

That's that for today Planes are definitely a new area, a new industry in our Company Forensics videos, but if you want to watch more of the videos that we've made check them out in the description See you next week Wherever you are in your entrepreneurial journey, if you want to be successful it's important that you have a community to support you That community is Trends Trends is an online network of thousands of entrepreneurs and

Investors working together All members get weekly early market signals, business case studies, and access to live lectures from founders, VCs, and top-tier agencies See how Trends will grow your business by visiting trendsco/deal

Related Videos

This video was brought to you by Slidebean Founder's Edition. Get help from our team in your pitch deck, your financial models, and your fundraising. Sign u...
This video was brought to you by Skillshare. By clicking the link in the description for a limited time the first thousand people will get a free trial of Skill...
in the late 90s apple was a ship without a captain closed the first quarter of 97 with 708 million dollars in burn rate it was a defining moment in the story o...
This video was brought to you by Monthly. Finally, a way to keep track of all your company SaaS expenses in one place. Get one free month by using the link in t...
This video was brought to you by NordVPN. Take control of your internet experience with 68% off a two-year plan with an additional month for free at NordVPN.com...
This video was brought to you by Skillshare. The first thousand people to join with the link in the description will get 2 free months on their premium membersh...
This video was brought to you by slide bean founders edition get help from our team in your pitch take your financial models and your fundraising sign up with t...
This video was brought to you by xyro the easiest way to get your brand online create your own website today using the link in the description and get a 30 off ...
This video was brought to you by slidebean founders edition get help from our team in your pitch take your financial models and your fundraising sign up with th...
This video was brought to you by the Slidebean Agency. Get the Design Team behind Slidebean to re-do your slides. Go to slidebean.com/agency and $50 off on your...
Raising venture capital is no easy task; many variables need to come into play and align for a round of funding to happen. We've covered extensively what a ...
As we've scaled sled beam and had the chance to connect with a bunch of companies one of the most common questions I get is around finding a co-founder the ...
Airbnb's original pitch deck from 2009 has become one of the most sought-after references for new entrepreneurs. It was one of the first pitch decks from un...
Each second of this video costs slide being around 2.5 dollars that's $10 just now around $150 per minute and around $1,200 for average video length of 8 mi...
This is the pitch deck that Uber used to raise their first round of funding, back in 2008. I think it's a fantastic example of a perfectly defined problem/s...
I started my first company back in 2010 since then I've had the chance to meet brilliant entrepreneurs with fantastic businesses on their hands however 9 ou...
If you're new to this channel, my name is Caya. I am the CEO of a company called Slidebean. Slidebean is my third startup. The other two failed and left me ...
Hello! Vini here from the Slidebean Team. Today, we’re gonna be looking at the slides Canva used to pitch their company to investors. Welcome back to pitch deck...
What if I started a new business today? How would I approach it? Let's imagine this scenario- Slidebean, the presentation platform I started in 2014 disappe...
Today we’re gonna be looking at the slides of a Swedish company, most of you have heard of, probably even used recently. This is a Spotify presentation. Today, ...